Is ScrumMaster the New Project Manager?

Shape Image One
Is ScrumMaster the New Project Manager?

As more and more organizations are moving towards Agile and Scrum there is a lot of confusion on the ScrumMaster Role and responsibility. I am sure you would have heard the term Agile Scrum Project Manager or Scrum Manager. These are a symptom of lack of understanding of the process.

The waterfall hangover  is the main culprit for this confusion on the role responsibilities, this happens because we are transcribing our understanding of  waterfall roles and process on to the Scrum Framework implementation.

The key difference between a traditional project manager and the scrum master are listed below

 Project Manager ScrumMaster 
 Part of a centralized decision-making process Works towards a de-centralized decision making process within the organization and team
 There is a defined hierarchy for information flow and   decision makingWorks towards a flatter organization for more effecient information flow
 Rarely works with the Product Manager to gather the   requirements Works constantly with the Product Owner to ensure that the Product Backlog is refined and the highest priority Items are ready to be planned
 Never works with the Product Manager to make sure they   understand the process Works with the Product Owner to make sure that the P.O understand they process.
 Works directly with the stakeholders on the requirements of the project Coaches stakeholders to work directly with the Product Owner. Ensures that the   Stakeholders are invited to the Sprint Review sessions and are active participants.
 Work with the managers of the various teams supporting the project i.e. Development Manager, Test Manager Work directly with the Development Team and ensure that they understand their responsibilities to deliver a high-quality product

Observations of how the ScrumMaster Role is misused in the Waterfall Hangover organization:

The ScrumMaster is the keeper of the tool and is tasked to update the tracking tool for whole team
They become a Scrum Mommy/Daddy for the team
Tells the team on what to work on a daily basis (Pseudo manager of the team)
Is a member of the development team while being a ScrumMaster as well
The functional manager (H.R Manager) is the ScrumMaster for the team
The technical lead is also the ScrumMaster and does all the planning and the refinement of the backlog and not involve the development team
ScrumMaster co-ordinates and delegates work to the development team

In conclusion the ScrumMaster role is more like a coach to the team and that organization. It has more to do with a personality type rather than the most technical person. The responsibilities of a ScrumMaster include:

Coach the team and the organization on the core principles and implementation of Scrum
Ensure that the team understands and takes on the responsibilities of being self-organizing and self-managing
Experiment with various ways and techniques to help the development team become better in self-organization and self-management.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *